Keurig vs. Ninja: Which is a Better Coffee Maker

Coffee makers have been additions to the home for decades and when two household names square off in the race for the best coffee maker only one will come out swinging. In one corner the Keurig K55, which is well known to make coffee, hot chocolate. With an awesome auto off feature that allows you to be sure that your coffee maker will not stay on all day if you forget to turn it off. Paired with a secondary water filter making sure you have the best beverages every day. The other, the Ninja is better known for a line of blenders that are cutting edge, but not for their wonderful coffee makers crafted with the name of Ninja Coffee Bar with a Glass Carafe (CF091). The Ninja has Advanced Thermal Flavor Extraction Technology, ensuring the best tasting coffee possible, along with a built in frother you can get all of your drinks in one place without hesitation. Today we’re going to pit them against one another and see what it takes to make the best cup of coffee for your morning.

What is Ninja Coffee Bar Brewer System

Ninja is a name most commonly associated with the blender series. But they also make the Ninja Coffee Bar Brewer system. When you make great products, why not make more great products? From classic to specialty coffee, and even iced coffee the Ninja is amazing. There are a wide variety of different coffee makers, from the single brew cup to the full carafe these coffee makers are pod free and environmentally friendly, allowing you to ensure your carbon footprint is seriously reduced.

What is Keurig Coffee Maker

Specifically designed for single cup brewing the Keurig is one of the household names in the United States. A common appliance in a kitchen these quick easy to use little coffee makers make your first cup of the morning super simple. Without overly complicating the process you can simply wake, pop in a pod, slide in a coffee cup and go. This makes the Keurig the go-to-coffee maker of America, no matter what contender they’re placed up against. It’s hard for coffee makers like the Ninja to beat out the competition when the competition all but rules over a marketplace. The Keurig is the single-serve king, and it’s difficult to push the coffee maker out of the limelight.

Keurig vs. Ninja

The Keurig is the most famous in the states. With easy to use pods and a quick and efficient method of depositing coffee into your cup this little device really captures attention Able to brew a wide variety of different things the Keurig is efficient and tiny, fitting into just about any space you need it to fit into. Efficient at creating a wide variety of different drinks, this is one versatile little machine.

The Ninja Coffee Bar is the new kid on the block, but one that is making some serious noise. With the ability to make all different kinds of coffee products it doesn’t matter how hot or cold the day is going to be for you, you’ll have delicious coffee brewed just the way you like it. The Ninja Coffee bar can patch together several different kinds of brews and ensures that no matter the differences in your household, coffee will never start another fight again. With the ability to craft and create even the most complex drinks at the push of a button. There is simplicity built into the new kid, and it is really making the Ninja Coffee Bar seem like an upstanding coffee maker.

Keurig K55 vs. Ninja CF091

 Keurig K55/K-Classic Coffee MakerNinja Coffee Bar Brewer System with Glass Carafe (CF091)
Keurig K55Ninja CF091
Cup Size6, 8, 10 ozCup, XL Cup, Travel, XL Multi-Serve, Half Carafe, Full Carafe
Brew TypeNo ControlClassic, Rich, Over-Ice, Specialty, Cafe Forte
Making Drinks Other Than Coffee Tea, coffee, and hot chocolateCoffee Only
Accessories 4 K-Cup pods and a water filter handle + 2 water filters5 Paper Filters, Measuring Scoop, Nina Easy Frother, 18oz. Ninja To-Go Tumbler w/ Lid, (40) Recipe Book
Price$78$169
BuyFromAmazonBuyFromAmazon

The Biggest Difference Between Ninja Coffee Bar and Keurig is:

Keurig relies on K-cups for its single-serve brewing. Coffee ground can be used with reusable K-cup filters. Ninja is a pod-free system. You don’t need any type of pods to brew coffee, just your favorite coffee ground.

Cup Size

The Ninja, depending on the model, has 6 or more different cup sizes, meaning that no matter the size of your cup you’ll find the right option for your needs. The Keurig has far fewer brewing options, usually one cup, and up to 3 different cup size options per device. The Ninja is far superior in this category. The different cup sizes allow you to pick and choose your amount of coffee without behind hindered or judged. You can have a tiny cup of coffee, or the biggest cup of coffee in the world without being hindered at all. Your coffee machine should work for you, and with the wide variety of cup sizes you’re going to be easily able to get the perfect cup of coffee out of every morning.

Brew Type

The Ninja Coffee Bar is able to make a wide variety of different brews. From solid bold coffee to iced coffee deliciousness the Ninja is able to do just about everything coffee related. The Keurig though is able to both make a wide variety of coffee and also make hot chocolate and other delicious hot beverages. It can’t make iced coffee though, and you can only choose the different pods to put in, unlike the Ninja, which allows you to brew a wide variety of different coffee types without a specialty pod. All you have to do is put in the coffee flavor you want, start to brew, and prep your taste buds.

Making Drinks Other Than Coffee

The Ninja Coffee Bar’s specialty is coffee. Iced coffee, bold coffee, original coffee, just about any kind of coffee the Ninja can make with very little effort. If you’re looking for something other than coffee the Keurig is the coffee maker to go with mostly because it can make hot chocolate and teas a well. The Ninja can manage to make those things as well, but it is a far more complicated process and you’ll need to clean the Ninja Coffee bar afterward. It’s best just for the Ninja Coffee Bar to stick with what it does best, making coffee. Coffee that rivals all other brews, no matter if its the single serve or carafe that’s brewed.

Accessories

With the Ninja Coffee Bar you can get a wide variety of additions. The first is an Easy Frother, to get the best foam for your lattes and cappuccinos. Another is a Coffee Caddy, and a Coffee and Spice Grinder. These additions are just a few of the many that can be added onto your Ninja Coffee Bar, giving you a better cup every single morning. These accessories are not mandatory, but they are in fact super useful to each machine depending on the model and accessories you aquire for them. They can make your life much easier, simpler, and more carefree that it would be without them.

The Keurig has a wide variety of additions as well, with a drawer that goes under your Keurig you can also add a moving carousel that can be rotated, adding this near your Keurig displays the pods, but that’s about it. It doesn’t have very many additions at all and it’s rare that the Keurig has any extra additions besides the pod holders. These pod holders come in different sizes and shapes but they all do the same thing, hold Keurig pods. These pods are essential to work the Keurig, but it’s not essential to have them on display.

Price

The Keurig usually costs roughly $100 which is significantly less than the $150 or more than the Ninja, but the Ninja has more additions and capabilities than the Keurig. So for more money you get a much better coffee maker that has variety and strength in each brew. The Keurig though is a cheaper option for those who aren’t terribly fussy over their coffee, and prefer to have a little hot chocolate from time to time. If you want a coffee maker that has the ability to make some okay coffee, along with other hot drinks, the Keurig is for you, but if you want restaurant quality coffee it’s always best to put your trust in a coffee maker that knows what it’s doing.

Which One to Buy

The one you should buy is up to you, it depends on what you want to get from your brewer. Tea, coffee, and hot chocolate are all options with the Keurig but the variety of just coffee products with the Ninja is difficult to pass up. If you only need coffee, tea, hot chocolate and more the Keurig is the best for you. You should also take into account clean up, filters, and other issues when you’re looking into buying either the Keurig or Ninja.

If you’re looking for just a delicious coffee maker the Ninja Coffee Bar is a wonderful addition to any kitchen as long as you need just coffee. Coffee is the focal point of the morning but occasionally wanting some hot chocolate, or tea instead of coffee is a common desire. Depending on if you need coffee or coffee and other hot drinks you should take into account the differences between the Ninja Coffee Bar and the Keurig.

Which Keurig to Buy? The Complete Keurig Buying Guide

Personal coffee making machines are popular for their quick and convenient usage. Keurig brewers are famous in the coffee machines market. Often it is the first choice consumers make, especially for single cup coffee maker.

When browsing coffee maker models, connoisseurs are often overwhelmed by the amount of models Keurig has. Making a clear choice can feel impossible, but a close comparison between models reveals underlining similarities.

This guide has been compiled by us to help you compare between different Keurig models. After reading this, you will find it easier to pick the machine that is suited for your needs.

Which Keurig to Buy

Best for Home UseKeurig K55 Coffee MakerBuyFromAmazon
Best for Office UseKeurig K145 OfficePRO Coffee MakerBuyFromAmazon
Best for Small SpaceKeurig K-Mini K15 Coffee MakerBuyFromAmazon

Keurig K55 Coffee Maker – Best for Home Use

Keurig K55 Coffee Maker
Keurig K55 Coffee Maker

The reason behind this machine’s success is its simplicity. The straightforward usage and lack of distracting buttons and knobs make this machine a joy to use.

The Keurig K55 coffee maker performs only one function and performs it well: making an extraordinary beverage. Single button usage and fast operation puts this model ahead of other more complicated but slower models.

The affordable price combined with a top quality cup of coffee gives this model an excellent reputation. Consumers love many things about this machine! If you search on the internet for this model, you will discover enthusiastic reviews. The affordability combined with high quality cups of coffee have contributed to this amazing reputation. To add further quality, Keurig has added a 1 year warranty for this particular model.

Here is a list of features for Keurig K55:

Highlighted features

  • The K55 is capable of making a variety of different beverages. From tea to coffee, hot chocolate, specialized drinks and even iced drinks.
  • This machine has multiple brewing sizes: 6, 8 and 10 ounces.
  • The K55 is a joy to use. All you have to do is lift the lever, pop in the flavor K-cup you desire, push the lever back down, and choose your brewing size.
  • Once the power button is pressed, the Keurig K55 begins to preheat. This serves the purpose of speeding up the brewing process, ensuring that your coffee is steamy hot and delicious each and every time. This model is renowned for brewing your beverage of choice in a minute or less.
  • This model features a 48 ounce water reservoir, which translates to 8 cups of your favorite beverage before requiring a refill. You won’t have to guess when the K55 is running low in water, there is an add water indicator. The removable design of water reservoir maks refilling and cleaning a true joy. No need to bring the entire machine into the sink when you can just remove the reservoir and easily pop it back into the machine.
  • This model features an easily programmable automatic off switch. When the Keurig is not in use for a certain period of time, it shuts off automatically.
  • Multiple Indicator lights inform the barista of what function the machine is performing at any given time. The lights at the top of the K55 are labeled: Add Water, Descale, Heating, Auto Off, and Power.
  • An easy-to-remove drip tray sets the way for easy cleaning. All the user has to do is gently pull the tray out of the body of the machine and run it under tap water. It is also possible to remove the tray to accommodate bigger glasses.
  • The Keurig K55 can use My K-Cup reusable coffee filters. This particular filter allows the user to brew their ideal coffee beans instead of being stuck with pre-packaged K-Cups. This feature allows for better usability and fresher cups of coffee!

User Opinions

Of all reviewers, 82% gave this coffee machine a 4 out of 5 star rating on Amazon. This is a great indicator of how satisfied people are with the K55.

One of the frequently mentioned benefits of this unit is the ease of use and overall simplicity in design. Home baristas love the option to pop in a K-Cup and have their favorite beverage in a snap of a finger.

Users mentioned how much they enjoyed the freedom of using the my K-Cup filter to brew any coffee variety they like.

The K55 preheats relatively quickly, being ready to use soon after the machine is powered on.

The build quality of this unit is exceptional, with the handle feeling sturdy as it moves to puncture the K-Cup.

People truly love the affordable price especially when compared to similar machines in its class.

Many users voice their appreciation for the spacious and removable water reservoir. They don’t worried about running out of water, a feature that especially comes in handy in households with multiple baristas. Because it is removable, all you have to do is walk over to your sink and fill it to capacity. Inferior units would require putting the entire unit in the sink to fill the water reservoir.

Conclusion

This eloquent yet sturdy machine is a pinnacle in design, featuring lighting fast brewing times and reliability. Appliance Savvy happily endorses the Keurig K55.

In this price range, this Keurig model beats all its opponents! The large and removable reservoir and quick usage alone makes it worth purchasing. We have been loyal Keurig customers for many years. With great faith we can say it truly is capable of everything we could ask for and more. When shopping for your next coffee maker, you would be wise to consider the Keurig K55!

>>> Read the customer reviews of Keurig K55 Coffee Maker

Keurig K145 OfficePRO Coffee Maker – Best for Office Use

Keurig K145 Coffee Maker
Keurig K145 Coffee Maker

The Keurig K145 is suggested for users who appreciate the “getting used to” of single-cup machines as well as the ease of use and variability that comes along with it.

Below you will learn about all the areas the K145 covers, where it can do better, and who the ideal customer would be.

Convenience

Like the previous model reviewed, the Keurig K145 also comes with a removable water reservoir. This makes it easy to refill and clean when necessary. Its capacity is 48 Oz. It fits perfectly into the unit, preventing outside dust and particle accumulation. The best part of this feature is the “Drain Brewer” button, allowing you to drain all the water so you can add fresh water.

The drop tray at the bottom of the machine is also easily removable, preventing annoying and time wasting spillage.

The K145 gets high scores for easy cleaning and maintenance.

Flexibility

Keurig revolutionized the coffee world with Flavored K-Cups. The K145 fits standard K-Cups, leaving the barista with hundreds of flavors to look forward to. This variety even features multiple options for tea and lemonade. there is truly something for everyone, not just coffee! Multiple beverage choices via a single machine. Amazing, right?

Further versatility is seen in the multiple cup sizes: 6 Oz. , 8 Oz. , and 10 Oz. Taste also differs among sizes. For seasoned coffee lovers, 8 Oz. features the perfect taste, but at 10 Oz. the coffee has been reported by some users to taste a little weak. With that said, you are free to experiment with multiple flavors and sizes before you find the option that is right for you. You even get a free trial pack of K-Cups with your patronage to Keurig!

It literally takes less than minute to brew a fresh cup. The built-in water reservoir further reduces the time it takes for consecutive cups.

The Keurig K145 suits the efficient American in office.

Built to Stand the Test of Time

The K145 has a heavier and better built housing, making it 2 lbs heavier than the K45. The internal pump is more powerful, reducing the brewing time comparatively. In addition, the heavy-duty power cable adds to its efficiency.

This unit was designed for a small restaurant or office in mind, making it relatively low maintenance and durable.

A frequently voiced complaint is the noise. Given the environment it is typically used in, it does not feature the Quit Brew Technology. This means it could reach loud noise levels. However, it is loudest in the first minute and bearable after that. Even at its loudest, it is still more quite than other kitchen appliances such as a mixer.

Importantly, this model is not compatible with My K-Cup. For baristas who require ground coffee, you are advised to look at other units.

Conclusion

If you prefer single cup coffee and desire an easy hassle free experience, then look no further than the Keurig K145 OfficePRO. It would most definitely be worthwhile to have on your countertop or office space. It is sturdy and doesn’t require much maintenance or cleaning. The design promotes usage of different sizes or flavors (tea and lemonade among others) and delivers reliable taste day in and out.

We would suggest this model over the Keurig K45 due to the features and positive user experience at a relatively higher cost. On the other hand, if your preference is ground coffee and My K-cup, then it is recommended you purchase the K45.

For users who like to begin their day with a steaming hot cup of coffee, the Keurig 2.0 offers programmable settings and would be the preferred machine.

>>> Read the customer reviews of Keurig K145 OfficePRO Coffee Maker

Keurig K-Mini K15 Coffee Maker – Best for Small Space

Keurig K15 Coffee Maker
Keurig K15 Coffee Maker

Design

The Keurig K15  is considered the most cost effective and small K-cup machine. The Mini is 10.8 inches tall and 6.9 inches wide, making it simple to move around. The dimensions make it ideal for people with limited counter-top space. While it doesn’t have carafe capability like the K20 model, the K15 fits all regular K-cups (with and without Keurig brand) and lets you make use of your own ground coffee. The design promotes simple usage, all you have to do is flip open the plastic lid located at the top of the reservoir. Then you use a cup to fill it, pick a K-cup flavor and push the brew button.

This single-use reservoir isn’t suited for everyone. The K15 requires a little time to warm up for each beverage you make. If you are a person who drinks lots of coffee, you would definitely want to spend a little more on a model that can brew multiple cups at once. A model like the K55 would suit you better, as it only needs to heat the water once to brew several cups consecutively.

Usability

The unit operation is kept simple. All you have to do is lift the lid off the reservoir, pour in the necessary amount of water and close the lid. Once the handle is lifted, water will begin to pour into the brewer. Once you have waited for all the water to drain, place your favorite K-cup into the holder and shut the handle. Push the Brew button (it will flash blue to notify you). Give the machine approximately 90 seconds to heat the water up and only an additional 20 seconds to dispense the beverage. The total time from brewing to drinking ranges averages about 2 minutes.

The K15 was designed with a single-use reservoir which requires filling for each cup of coffee you desire. This is a feature I did not enjoy at first, but I realized later this is an advantage. It ensures the water is fresh, an important variable when brewing quality coffee. Adding fresh water to the machine couldn’t be any easier. Fill your cup with fresh water, lift the lid and pour it into the machine. The reservoir is even located at the top of the unit for added convenience.

Unlike the other Keurig models mentioned above, the K15 doesn’t have buttons that are designed solely for each cup size. However, there are measurements in the water reservoir that show how much water to add for your desired beverage size. 6,8, or 10 ounces are available. Just add the water and let it reach the appropriate fill level and you’re in business! Simple and effective.

This machine fits all regular K-cups and is also compatible with My K-cup reusable filters. The removable drip tray means it also fits larger mugs.

Customer Service and Maintenance

The Keurig K15 comes with a limited one-year warranty that covers typical home usage. In order to keep your K15 in functional shape, it is suggested you clean the external parts of the brewer regularly. You should descale the unit every 3 ~ 6 months. Luckily, all you must do is detach the brew head which comes off with the click of a button. Customer service is just a phone call away, and is available 7 days a week at 866-901-BREW (866-901-2739).

>>> Read the customer reviews of Keurig K-Mini K15 Coffee Maker

Features to Consider When You Choose Keurig Models

It can be hard to keep all the different important features in mind when deciding between models. Here is a list that will get you going. Keep in mind your own unique needs when comparing models. These mainly apply to the K-Cup Brewing System models, are also suitable to other models as well.

Where the Machine Will Be Used

Most Keurig models are labeled UL and suggested for Household use only. If you plan on using the machine in an office, commercial building or some dorms you would benefit from a brewer that is listed for commercial use. Read on to learn more about why UL labels matter when choosing a single cup coffee maker.

Machine Size

If you have a tiny counter, you are most likely worried about the amount of space each machine will take up. Another concern might be if it will fit properly under upper cabinets. You can always set up a dedicated brewing station in or near the kitchen. You will find more suggestions and ideas here or on out Coffee Organizers Pinterest board.

Cup Size

Certain machines brew only a single cup size, while other models allow you to choose between 4-12 ounces per cup. Just keep in the back of your mind, the more water you use the milder the taste will be.

Brew Time

Most Keurigs typically only need a minute or less to heat up water from the reservoir and begin brewing. The Mini plus (without a water reservoir) can take 2-3 minutes. This is still much faster than other typical coffee brewing methods. When you add water, it is advised you use water that is room temperature. Otherwise, the wait for your favorite warm beverage will be longer.

Reservoir Build and Size

The Mini plus has a water tank that fits one cup of coffee. This means you must refill the machine each time you use it. The other models have removable reservoirs that makes it easier for you to fill it in your sink. The capacity for these tanks range from 40 to 80 ounces. These models also keep hot water ready for the quickest brewing and dispensing for other purposes.

Hot Water Dispensing

All Keurig Models have the capability of producing hot water for tea, hot chocolate or even instant oatmeal, etc. Some models allow access to this capability better than others. If this is a function that you place a lot of emphasis on, be sure to choose a machine with a hot water button.

Drip Tray

A drip tray is handy for cleaning spills and is typically day to remove. Removing the tray or turning it over usually allows for brewing of taller mugs (like a travel mug).

My K-Cup Usability

Not every machine is suitable for use with the My K-Cup filter (or other similar reusable filters). None of the 2.0 machines or commercial machines do ( the K155 is the exception). If you prefer to use K-Cup, then any Keurig model would best suit you. If you prefer to use your own grind, then the Mini Plus, Elite or OfficePro Premiere (which is also suited for home use).

Quiet Brew Feature

Most models have a feature called Quite Brew technology. This allows for quite coffee making. The only two models that don’t are the K10 Mini Plus and the OfficePro, so these machines are comparatively louder.

Energy Saving

Typical Keurig models have a feature that powers off automatically in 90 seconds after brewing is finished. The OfficePro has an auto shut off after 2 hours.

Programmable Feature

If you look forward to a steaming hot cup of coffee every morning, you can easily program certain models to be ready when you are.

Water Feed Plumbing Kit

The B150 and B155 models feature an optional plumbing kit that allows you to attach a water line to feed the water tank. This saves time and prevents trips to the sink. Do not forget that the B155 was also built for home use.

Water Filtering

You have the option of a water filter that can eliminate distracting tastes if present in your water.